Tabletop RPG · since 2020 · #79 most discussed

Alice is Missing

A silent, GM-less game played over text messages, where friends search for a missing girl and share growing dread.

GM-lessMysteryGM-lesstokenscardsinvestigationsafety tools built inOne-shotsNo GM
7.1
Geek rating

From 33 firsthand play reports in 6 r/rpg threads. The threads alone average 7.8.

Player rating— / 10

No visitor ratings yet.

Discussion5.6 / 10

111 r/rpg posts named it, October 2023 to October 2026.

Rules weight

Light. Hype 4.6 for its age.

Have you played it?

Rate Alice is Missing from 1 to 10. One rating per browser and device; you can change it any time.

Didn't work for usOne of our best

What players say

At the table

Alice Is Missing is a GM-less, text-message game where players roleplay friends of a missing girl against a timer. Most reports describe an urgent, emotional session. It works best when the table treats it as collaborative improv, not a mystery to solve.

What works

What tables struggle with

Who it suits

In players' words

The threads behind it

Each thread is rated for the play it describes, from the firsthand reports in it. Load one here or read it on Reddit.

8.3

Alice is Missing looks very interesting

Players who ran or played Alice Is Missing mostly describe an intense, urgent, often tearful session. The timer and text-message format drive it, and it works best when everyone commits to roleplaying. A few tables found it less emotional than the hype suggested, were confused about the goal, or had the mood broken by players who joked around. 19 firsthand · 37 comments

Open on Reddit
7.0

Alice is Missing No Spoilers Advice request

People who played Alice is Missing mostly report that it works well once they understand it is a story-driven roleplaying game and not a puzzle. Setup is long, and a couple of players were put off because the marketing led them to expect a mystery to solve. 8 firsthand · 13 comments

Open on Reddit
5.0

Fixing "Alice is Missing"

The only firsthand reports are the original poster and one commenter who played twice. They enjoyed the group-chat roleplay but felt let down because the ending (where Alice is and who is responsible) comes from a random card draw that nothing the players said or did could affect. Much of the thread is debate from people who may not have played, and a long tangent about For the Queen, which was ignored. 2 firsthand · 16 comments

Open on Reddit
8.5

Alice is Missing : is my discord idea playable and enjoyable?

The thread is mostly about how to run Alice is Missing over Discord, and only two commenters describe having played it. Both were positive: the original poster loved an online game with strangers, and another commenter ran it on Discord and Roll20 and called it a perfect fit for online play. 2 firsthand · 24 comments

Open on Reddit
9.0

Something similar to Alice is Missing or Ten Candles?

Only the original poster describes playing Alice is Missing. They were doubtful about it beforehand, then found it more immersive than any RPG they had played, and it led them to look for similar games. The rest of the thread is recommendations for other games, such as Dialect, Dread, Brindlewood Bay and Fall of Magic, with no other play reports of Alice is Missing. 1 firsthand · 20 comments

Open on Reddit
8.5

Games similar to Alice is Missing

The thread is almost entirely about other games. Its only firsthand report of Alice is Missing is the original poster's, who says the group loved it, especially the equal say everyone had in the story. The one drawback was that five players felt small and some couldn't attend. 1 firsthand · 30 comments

Open on Reddit